October 2026 Book Bracket

Book Bracket for October 2026 

September was a light reading month, and I know I was hopeful of getting more books finished in October, but I sure did not expect to read or listen to 15! And I'm excited by how many books I read that I thought were good, and made working through the bracket a brutal business.

A Redwall Winter's Tale, by Brian Jacques

This lengthy picture book, set in the world of Redwall following the events of Redwall, describes the entertainment, snowfall, and frolicking visited upon the abbey at the opening of winter.

Why I picked it up: This was a spontaneous pick while I was allowing myself a few unnecessary books at the library. Why not read a Brian Jacques book that I've never read before?

My impressions: While lacking in compelling plot, the cozy illustrations and familiar Redwall elements made this work one that would likely warm the heart of any Redwall fan. It felt like a pretty fitting introduction to the world of Redwall, like where a youngster might start who's watched the TV show but is too young to read the mainline books of the series. I enjoyed the whimsical art, which was appropriate for the age of the intended audience. One aspect that didn't work as well for me was the frequent transitioning from prose to poetry to prose again. The poems differed in their rhyming schemes and meters, failing to follow a clear pattern. This work would be great for readers who want to dip their toes into the Redwall world but aren't old enough for the bigger books in the series.

Mr. Standfast, by John Buchan, narrated by Frederick Davidson**

The third Richard Hannay adventure follows this special agent as he and his coworkers work to wrangle the most dangerous spy to infiltrate British territory during the first World War - and as he falls in love.

Why I picked it up: I needed a break from the very serious Silent Spring audiobook I was listening to, and decided an action spy book was just the ticket. I'd seen this third installment recommended on a website that listed great adventure books, and figured I'd give it a try. I think I listened to the second audiobook within the last year.

My impressions: I think I liked this one better than the second one, Greenmantle, although I found the final act to be a little too slow of a denouement. I've never read The Pilgrim's Progress, but knew enough about it to find it interesting that Mr. Standfast was a sort of mirror to that classic work. It was fun to see interesting characters from the previous book return for this adventure, and while there wasn't much character development, each person appeared as a fully realized individual. Racist comments dot the book, and there was some stereotyping of the German enemies, as well as some comments about considering suicide an option if escape wasn't possible. And how about a love interest that is less than half the protagonist's age? I found some elements of the book to be a little predictable, especially given that characters repeatedly refer to events they fear will happen, but I didn't anticipate all the details from the beginning (I never do). The last part of the book does describe a deadly battle, but I found there was little gore described, even when characters died. This book would be a good read for those who want a not-too-deep action story set during a war - as long as they can overlook its shortcomings. 

Magnificent Humanity, by Pope Leo XIV

Pope Leo XIV's first encyclical, published earlier this year in May, is all about how to build a just society in the age of artificial intelligence.

Why I picked it up: I've been developing (mostly negative) hot takes on AI since it got big about three years ago, and with all my delving into the dangers of screens for young brains in the last few years, it made sense that I'd pick up the pope's work at some point. A friend reminded me that it's okay to read things just a paragraph at a time, and that helped me get started.

My impressions: This was a great work. I was impressed by it's scope and the pope's grasp of so many topics. I liked his imagery when he asked if we're using AI to build a better world together, like the rebuilding of the walls of Jerusalem during Nehemiah's time, or if we're just building a tower of Babel. His review of the history of Catholic Social Teaching was pertinent and much appreciated by me, who have not reviewed it since I first learned about it in high school. The second half of the book was probably the most interesting part for me, because that's where he really gets into AI, its dangers, and how it could and should be used on behalf of supporting the dignity of human beings. I underlined many lines and would recommend this book to anyone, Catholic and non-Catholic, who wants to consider the implications of AI in our time.

When Life Gives You Pears: The Healing Power of Family, Faith, and Funny People, by Jeannie Gaffigan

Wife of comedian Jim Gaffigan, and mother of five, recounts how her life was turned upside-down when a pear-shaped tumor was discovered growing in her brain.

Why I picked it up: This book came onto my to-read list at some point while I listened to the Fountains of Carrots podcast (RIP, podcast; the website isn't maintained, so you can't really listen to episodes anymore), because Jeannie Gaffigan was a guest on it. This book was also available at the library when I treated myself to a little library adventure, so I figured - sure, I could use another book to distract me from required reading! And it came home with me.

My impressions: There was a lot to pull me in and make me laugh, especially in the first third of the book. I don't know why, but I had trouble putting it down during that first portion. There was a lot of drama inherently built into the story (how does one learn that a tumor is growing in one's brain?), and the author does a great job of communicating what her experience felt like - the anxiety of uncertainty, the peace that washed over her during prayer, the fear that she expressed as anger. I liked Gaffigan talking about how she grew in her faith and relationship with God, although there were several instances of using the Lord's Name in vain. I enjoyed hearing about her family, but the book seemed to lose some of its focus towards the end, and the ending was a little...I'm not sure, not quite my taste. I'm not sure why we learned about how she and Jim met and married at the end of the book, although I think I can catch the thread as I think back on it. There were parts that made me cry, sections that warmed my heart, and parts that I thought, "Yup, that sounds familiar," thinking back on the surgeries I've had. There were a couple sections that maybe would be more for an adult audience, but other than a smattering of jokes that made me uncomfortable...or were just plain bad...this entertaining book could be a good read for folks who want an inside look at how a cancer diagnosis and successful treatment and change a how a person's life looks, and change that person herself.

Tuesdays at the Castle, by Jessica Day George, narrated by Suzy Jackson**

Princess Cecilia lives with her family in a mysterious and fun castle that introduces new rooms and takes unused ones away every week, but she and her siblings must rely upon themselves and the castle's aid when their parents are believed dead from an ambush.

Why I picked it up: A family member brought up the series, and I recalled having read the first three books, I think before the last two of the series came out. I wanted to revisit them, and these were available as audiobooks through my public library's e-system.

My impressions: This is a fun and intriguing listen. I love the world building regarding the castle's involvement in the story. There's something charming about living in a fantasy world with a sentient castle, and it's so creative. The story's action relied quite a bit on political intrigue, but it didn't overwhelm the story. This time, as I listened, I reflected on how the castle could be something of a symbol for God; the castle provides for and protects the children, but it is mysterious and something that, at best, cooperates with requests - it is not under the control of people. It even "comes back" after what seems to be a fatal disaster. The characterization is pretty good, everyone having their own personality. There were a few bits that weren't perfect - such as some gross acts employed to irritate some enemies within the castle - but overall, I'd say nothing objectionable about this book and a fun little fantasy jaunt for mid- or upper-elementary readers.

The King's Equal, by Katherine Paterson

This short fairy tale shows how a poor shepherdess changes a proud, greedy prince into a humble and wise ruler after showing she is more than his equal.

Why I picked it up: This one had been on my to-read list, and I finally tracked it down after reading one of Paterson's books of essays about writing for children. I checked it out from my local library.

My impressions: This was a very short chapter book, but a sweet fairy tale written in the classic style. I wouldn't say it has quite the charm of The Ordinary Princess, but I appreciated the quality of the writing. It would be a great book for a mid-elementary reader who likes fairy tales.

Prayer Primer: Igniting a Fire Within, by Thomas Dubay, S.M.

This book walks Catholics through the beginning stages of prayer, but also gives an overview of more advanced prayer (contemplation) and addresses common questions and concerns about prayer.

Why I picked it up: I picked up this book from a church garage sale several years ago. It's been sitting on my shelf since then, but I finally picked it up after resolving to use my Sunday reading on strictly religious works.

My impressions: I'm grateful God gave the idea for the Sunday reading resolution, because this book has been very good for me. I feel called out by it in some ways, but stretched and realizing I need to do more. In spite of being a Catholic all my life, there are some ways in which I'm still just a beginner at prayer. This book was good to take to adoration, and good to read on Sunday afternoons at home. It's giving me something to discuss with my spiritual director, and making me think about how I can live with more authentic love for God and His Church. I don't doubt I'll need to revisit at least some sections of it in the future. I recommend this book to all Catholics, high school and older, who could use some information about prayer - even for those who think they know quite a bit about prayer, this book could be helpful. I think middle schoolers could also benefit from reading this book.

Wednesdays in the Tower, by Jessica Day George, narrated by Suzy Jackson**

The royal Glower children strive to help their distressed castle, even as Cecilia tries to hide the griffin that hatched from a hidden egg and a mysterious wizard begins meddling with their efforts.

Why I picked it up: I'd listened to the previous audiobook and was ready to tackle this second one, also available through my local public library's e-system.

My impressions: Less political intrigue, but the story didn't feel quite as tightly written as the first tale. The stakes also started off much lower, but it gave the story time to build. I like that we're learning more about the castle, but also given more questions about it than answers. This book is a solid sequel to the original story, even though it develops along very different lines than the first one. It would be a good book for those upper-elementary and older readers who have read the first book in the series.

Thursdays with the Crown, by Jessica Day George, narrated by Grace Andrews**

This third book in the Tuesdays at the Castle series shares the adventure of the Glower children and their friends in a different world, the world that originated their magical castle, as they navigate perils between two old, warring wizards.

Why I picked it up: I was ready for the third book in the series. This was the last one I read when I was trying out this series for the first time.

My impressions: It was interesting to see the youths in a different setting, but the adventure was somewhat lacking. Yes, things happened, but since it was a rather impoverished world, the atmosphere did not make me feel like this was an exciting place to be. I think there were some pretty good developments, including learning more about the castle, but there were some notable flaws. First, the stand-out first king who built the castle had five wives. One of the royal children comments on that situation being something like his greatest achievement. Yikes. Yes, it's a fantasy tale, but no thanks to polygamy. Another flaw was that the warring wizards often appeared to be just childish liars rather than the truly evil baddies they were meant to be. This book would be good for upper elementary readers and beyond who've read the first two books, with the understanding that the subject of polygamy comes up, and that may be something to discuss.

So Big, by Edna Ferber*

Selina, the orphaned daughter of a gambler, marries a serious, poor Dutch vegetable farmer and, upon his death, takes on responsibility for her future and the welfare of her son by working in the fields herself.

Why I picked it up: It's the first required read for a book club this year. I was glad to acquire it as an ebook for free since it's in the public domain.

My impressions: The characters were so well written that I found myself thinking about them even when I wasn't reading, but I can't say the plot or writing style were quite my cup of tea. This is an award-winning book, and I can see how it would be, but I don't know if I'll reread it. It was a strange mixture of being about Selina's life, and then being about her son's, so the narrative was well connected, but odd to have two foci. I took issue with the implication that "beauty" and "self-expression" are interchangeable terms. What even is self-expression? Isn't beauty something that we can recognize outside ourselves, that's most captivating when we're not focused on how we express ourselves? Anyway, it's a book that certainly hails from a different time period. I didn't like it enough to recommend others read it, but it could be a good match for some folks out there. I'm interested to hear what the gals at book club have to say.

Fridays with the Wizards, by Jessica Day George, narrated by Grace Andrews**

The fourth installment of the Castle Glower series follows Cecilia, her royal Glower family, devoted griffin pets, and friends as they attempt to shut down an escaped, evil wizard who is causing trouble and growing increasingly dangerous.

Why I picked it up: It was the next book in the series, and the first of the two remaining books that I hadn't read yet. Available through my public library's e-system.

My impressions: This book helpfully ties up some loose ends, while continuing to develop the castle's lore and exploring griffin-rider relations. It is a solid work, with appropriately high stakes, and, in my opinion, a better book than the one preceding it. The story felt like it developed at a good pace. I admit I lost focus a few times while I worked on a scrapbooking project, particularly during the more magic-based action moments, but the story is definitely still intriguing. Those who read the first three books should find this one to be an enjoyable continuation of the series.

Saturdays at Sea, by Jessica Day George, narrated by Grace Andrews**

The final installment of the series begun by Tuesdays at the Castle takes a nautical turn as Cecilia, several family members, and friends embark to a different country to formalize a royal engagement, and then take what was intended to be a short jaunt around the bay in a ship that shares the same magic as the castle.

Why I picked it up: I needed to keep my brain busy; I was working on a scrapbooking project; and I wanted to finish the series. Again, available through the local library's e-system.

My impressions: This book was fresh and interesting and its own unique work, which is quite impressive considering it's book number five in the series. It wraps up loose ends, continues to hearken back to the castle even when they're in a different country, and gives readers a satisfying ending. I did notice that the regal mother, Queen Celina, stoops to forging money through her wizardly skills, but that's a pretty minor complaint. It gives a happy ending without being saccharine, and while it doesn't spell out everything that's going to happen, it certainly gives a few hints as to what relationships may develop in the future. Readers could live happy lives by reading the first four books and not this one, but they shouldn't - this was a good ending to the series.

The Kitchen Madonna, by Rumer Godden

Gregory, a serious child who shows little outward affection, takes as his mission the effort to make the family's Ukrainian cook, Marta, happy by providing her with an icon for the kitchen.

Why I picked it up: I spoiled myself at the library by indulging in picking up eight books, 6 of them novels. Though this one is misidentified in the system as an adult book (it's a children's novel), the comparatively few number of pages were quite welcome.

My impressions: This isn't the book to reach our and grab a reader from page one; it's a slow, reflective sort of book, but absolutely worth picking up. It is a great children's book and a lovely example of realistic fiction, showing children dealing with a problem that is real and dealt with in a way that would be attainable to child readers. There is something charming about seeing a boy decide how he's going to craft a Madonna and Child icon with materials that are available to him - and have it turn out. The illustrations in the book work wonderfully with the written material, and they really enrich the reading experience. There was one element of Godden's writing that perhaps wasn't my favorite - a way of expressing a thought or sentiment of some character or another - but otherwise, I think it was very good and focused writing. The book is subtle. I'd say it requires some patience, or at least a willingness to take it in slowly. But I absolutely think this is a book worth reading, for children and adults alike.

Once a Queen, by Sarah Arthur

Eva visits her estranged British grandmother one summer, and strives to uncover family secrets while coming to terms with the possibility that her favorite fantasy tales might just be true.

Why I picked it up: This book came home from the library along with seven other titles. It had been on my to-read list, but it's a fairly new book - published in 2024.

My impressions: This book explores generational trauma, so it's a little heavier than a middle grade novel (ergo, its location on the YA shelf), but it very much shares the spirit of The Chronicles of Narnia. In fact, one can't help but notice how Lewis' books influenced this one. Part potential portal fantasy adventure, part quasi-mystery, I found that the author's slow rate of revealing information to be aggravating, yet effective at making me want to keep reading to find out more. I thought some of the language connected with the fantasy world to be a little stilted - sounding just a little too archaic - but overall, the myths of that world were developed satisfactorily most of the time. I think the author's themes were perhaps a little too on the nose at times, but at the same time, it was nice that her message of hope was not lost in subtleties. I was irritated by Eva's family being so secretive - there didn't seem to be any good reason that so much of her family's history was withheld from her. Also, I found it odd that so much of the mythology was pointedly focused on female characters. There is much "yes, but" happening in this review, but I did enjoy this book and I hope to read the next two books as soon as my busy reading schedule will allow. This book is perfect for readers who grew up loving the "Chronicles of Narnia" books and can handle content that's a little heavier than Lewis' books.

The Last Battle, by C. S. Lewis, narrated by Sir Patrick Stewart**

The final book in the "Chronicles of Narnia" series details the last days of Narnia and the homecoming of all the beloved characters to a special place.

Why I picked it up: This book is part of a book club I've been doing with relatives. I listened to the audiobook version I obtained from Audible.

My impressions: This is only my third time reading the book, which I've avoided because I don't like how sad it is. That issue was almost completely overcome in this experience of listening to Sir Patrick Stewart read it, at 2x speed, in audiobook form. Perhaps I wasn't able to dwell too much on how everything was going wrong. Or, perhaps, I was able to experience more of the glimmerings of hope that showed here and there in the midst of tragic events. The adventure elements of the story were pretty good, but it did feel like there was more focus on less action-y doings in this book than in the previous ones. The pacing at the end also felt a little bit off, with a longer denouement than one finds after the climax. However, I will say that this book is one of the best that I've ever read that portrays Heaven in a beautiful and desirable way. While not my favorite in the series, this is a must-read for fans of Lewis' Narnia books.

Bracket Play

What a month for reading! I arranged the bracket as well as I could in the first round, trying to match weaker books with my favorites from this month, and trying to help the favorites get as far as they could.

Though the Tuesdays at the Castle series was quite enjoyable, I knew those books wouldn't be my favorite from the month, so the were all knocked out by the end of the second full round. Jeannie Gaffigan's humorous memoir about being diagnosed with a brain tumor, having surgery, and recovering was certainly not a perfect book, but there were a lot of elements about it that I liked, so it also made it to the second round, where it fell to the excellent, sweet, simple book by Rumer Godden, The Kitchen Madonna. I would've like to see Lewis' The Last Battle make it further into the competition, but as it's not one of my favorites in the Narnia series, I felt like I could live with it experiencing an early defeat. Similarly, Paterson's The King's Equal was good, but I could live with it losing early to Gaffigan's book.

The two Catholic works were also difficult to choose between...they were both excellent for very different reasons...but in the end, I chose the pope's encyclical, just because it's so timely and I think a good hallmark work for this year. That work also beat out the imperfect but surprisingly gripping and fairly new fantasy novel, Once a Queen. I look forward to continuing the series, but I was glad The Kitchen Madonna was the last contender before Magnificent Humanity took the win for this month. 

If you've read this far, I hope you'll try one of the excellent books I read this month!

Books Attempted and Put Down

Silent Spring, by Rachel Carson, narrated by Kaiulani Lee**

The landmark work on the harms of toxins, especially those found in pesticides, on the environment and the organisms - including humans - that live in them.

Why I picked it up: I'd heard this was a famous work, and had some impression that it might including some interesting stories, so I checked out an audiobook version through the public library.

Why I put it down: It was long, and it had heavy content - I didn't need to hear story after story about people being poisoned or permanently handicapped by the products that were being used widespread to fight the pests that eat crops. Looking at the book bracket, I'm glad I put it down because it made a lot more room for the many books I did finish this month!

September 2026 Book Bracket

September Book Bracket

A quiet month for reading. I was pleased to finish a book that was a big time commitment - The Evidential Power of Beauty - as well as three other books that were either partially finished or sitting in my to-read pile at home. I was disappointed in three books I attempted, but was glad to move them out of my to-read pile or off the to-read list.

The Evidential Power of Beauty: Science and Theology Meet, by Thomas Dubay, S.M.

A priest reflects on the ways that scientific research and Catholic theology agree about beauty.

Why I picked it up: I attempted this before, after it was recommended by a cousin, and lost interest soon after the first chapter. I made this second effort in the summer, realizing I needed to read it as research for a writing project. There's also the desire to read more of the books that are sitting, unread, on my shelves at home.

My impressions: This book is academic without being painfully so, but it takes a serious commitment to work through it. It felt like an intellectually stimulating work that was just within what I felt I could comfortably follow, at least for the most part. I'm glad I persevered this time through, because it was a good and thorough study of its subject, and I gained information and new insights relevant to the writing project. The author had read widely and knowledgeably in many fields, but referred often to some of his favorite authors - the most notable of which was Hans Urs von Balthasar. In fact, I wonder if maybe this is a somewhat more accessible, single-volume variation of von Balthasar's multi-volume work The Glory of the Lord, referenced throughout by Dubay. This book would be good for Catholic readers seeking an intellectual and well-researched work about the intersection of science and faith on the topic of beauty.

The House of Sixty Fathers, by Meindert DeJong

During World War II, Tien Pao, separated from his family, tries to escape from behind enemy lines with the family pig to rejoin them.

Why I picked it up: This is a book that's been on my to-read list for ages - probably one of the earliest books to show up on the list - and I found a free copy when a teacher was giving away her classroom library.

My impressions: This book had a slow start and I wasn't sure if I'd be able to get into it, but I found it exciting and of excellent quality. I didn't realize this book was also by the author who wrote The Wheel on the School, which was too slow for me, but this one was much better as far as being an engaging story. The subject matter might be difficult for some, as DeJong details some of the realities of war and starvation, but I felt like he said no more than he had to, and often had the characters turning their heads away from something particularly horrendous. Tien Pao's reactions had the feel of verisimilitude, so much so that I wondered if this story might have arisen from the author's own experience - I think it must have, at least in part. I felt that the title referenced one of the least important parts of the book, but it was still a good story. My favorite part of this book was witnessing the joy of reunion between Tien Pao and his family; it really gets to the heart of the love parents have for their children. This would be a good book for more mature middle schoolers who can handle some more difficult content related to war.

The Coral Island, by R. M. Ballantyne*/** (audiobook narrated by Tom Weiss)

This tale of shipwreck and survival details the account of three youths who must survive on a bountiful coral island in the midst of waters that are plied by pirates and cannibals.

Why I picked it up: A friend of mine mentioned this title in reference to my appreciation for survival tales. I read just over half of it in e-book form, and finished it in audiobook form on Librivox.

My impressions: Well, this book has many racist views throughout, but I also found the first person narrator to be too wordy. Details of surviving on the island were just too numerous, and it didn't seem like the trio had a hard time doing it - there was a bounty of food all around them. Finally, a little after the halfway mark, one of the characters leaves the island, and more of a plot forms, but it took to long to get to that point. There are multiple instances of graphic violence and I wondered how much of the story was sensationalistic. I will say that author did a fine job of distinguishing the personalities of the trio, so that was a good point for this book. I'm afraid I don't have much else to say in its favor. There are many excellent survival-on-island stories out there, and I'd recommend one of those, not this one.

Far North, by Will Hobbs

Gabe moves north to be close to his dad, but finds himself facing the brutal wilderness of Canadian winter when the bush plane which carried the pilot, himself, his schoolmate Raymond, and Dene elder Johnny Raven fails.

Why I picked it up: I picked up this book for free from my parish's elementary school; they were getting rid of tons of books, and this survival tale looked like it was just my type of story.

My impressions: There was a lot of danger to overcome and plenty of action in this story, with one part being particularly gripping. The perils seemed realistic without being a manual of "how to survive a winter in Canada". There was some good incorporation of Native American characters and traditions as well, although some of the more spiritual practices seemed to lean harder into pre-Christian beliefs than orthodox Christianity. Besides the Native American spirituality, I don't recall there being anything that would be troubling about the book, other than the death of some individuals and the descriptions and death of game animals that were hunted for food. I liked the strong emphasis on learning from one's elders and holding on to traditions, as well as the theme of friendship and the sheer grit shown by the characters. This could be a good survival story for some readers, such as those who enjoyed Hatchet, but it's not impressive enough for me to keep this copy or plan to reread it.

Bracket Play

Few books means an easy bracket! I had three survival tales and one theological book about beauty, so I was able to pick one of the weaker survival stories against Dubay's academic work. The best survival story, The House of Sixty Fathers, was not the typical survival story, as it was about surviving in a war-torn and famine-stricken land, but I was able to give it a placement on the bracket that took it to the next round.

In the second and final round, Dubay's academic work beat The House of Sixty Fathers. The winning book was wide-ranging, well-written and researched, and thought-provoking. I'm glad I finally committed to giving it the time it deserved.

Books Attempted and Put Down

Our Only May Amelia, by Jennifer L. Holm

May Amelia lives with her Finnish-American family (parents and male-only siblings) on the Pacific Coast at the turn of the century, and her adventurous, lonely girl-heart yearns for a younger sister.

Why I picked it up: I think this was on a recommended reading list somewhere, and I picked it up for free when a teacher was getting rid of her classroom books.

Why I put it down: I was enjoying this book, in spite of a few elements that would've prevented me from recommending it (swearing and using the Lord's name in vain, mention of harlots, brief descriptions of old neighbors killing themselves, etc.), but when tragedy strikes a treasured family member, I couldn't deal with it and put down the book. An older family member is so cruel, and I wasn't going to hang around for another several dozen pages to see a traumatized and distraught May Amelia finally get herself turned around and into a better place. Reading up on a summarized version of the ending was plenty good enough for me.

The Winter People, by Joseph Bruchac

A young Native American sets out to rescue his mother and sisters after his peaceful village is attacked by English colonists in a surprise raid.

Why I picked it up: Based off the cover, I thought I'd enjoy the book. I actually found two copies at some point.

Why I put it down: The book wasn't engrossing me, there was kind of a weird mix of Catholic beliefs and Native American spirituality, and I just wasn't convinced I wanted to keep dedicating time to reading it. I'm alright with trying this out, realizing it's not for me, and getting rid of it.

Everything Sad is Untrue, by Daniel Nayeri**

Nayeri writes a rambling account of his lived experience being a child refugee from Iran living in Edmund, Oklahoma, and trying to keep his memories and heritage alive even as he tries to fit into his new country.

Why I picked it up: It was recommended by Haley Stewart as a children's book that embodies "hope".

Why I put it down: I wasn't picking up much on what made the book so hopeful for Stewart. I made it about 30-40% of the way through the book before deciding that I was interested in what was happening, but it didn't appear to be bearing good fruit in my life. There was a lot of infidelity, divorce, and a reference or two to sex in this book, which also did not help recommend itself to me. There were lots of elements that worked for this book: an engaging narrator, references to the Thousand and One Arabian Nights (albeit with more adult content in a few of those references), and some good writing that helped me easily picture what was going on. He called out cruelty and indifference as evil, explaining sins of omission without using that actual phrasing, so I can see how this could be a good book for some, although it wasn't for me.

August Book Bracket 2026

 Book Bracket August

The start of school meant a serious drop-off in my reading habits. However, I'm grateful to have finished the following books.

Belisarius: The First Shall Be Last, by Paolo Belzoni, read by AI-generated voice**

This historical fiction work follows the life of a young man, Belisarius, as he trains in the army, learns strategy, and begins battling the Persians.

Why I picked it up: I think this book was recommended on a list at some point, and I obtained it with an Audible credit a while ago.

My impressions: This wasn't the most engaging work of historical fiction, but it wasn't terrible, either. It felt a little like a biography with a little more story to it, and I think that's why the final showdown was not the exciting pinnacle I hoped it would be. I think there was a decent sense of the decline of Roman power, including military might, which prepares the ground for Belisarius' rise to fame. There were comments here and there that referred to mature topics, such as getting drunk and sleeping around with women, so this isn't something that would be appropriate for just any middle schooler. I think the focus on military action would make this book more interesting to boys than to girls, but I don't think this book is necessary to read.

The Medieval Mind of C. S. Lewis: How Great Books Shaped a Great Mind, by Jason M. Baxter

A scholar describes how C. S. Lewis' professional interest in Medieval works was more than just professional, and the many ways it influenced his creative writing.

Why I picked it up: A friend expressed excitement about reading a different work that had been translated by this author, and I figured this book would be worth a try. Available through my public library system.

My impressions: This book helped answer some questions about some works of Lewis that I'd read previously, including  Till We Have Faces. I felt like my previous reading of many of Lewis' works made me already familiar with some of the points Baxter was making, including Lewis' love of the Medieval model, but he deepened my knowledge in some areas. This book would probably be most interesting to adults who are already fans of C. S. Lewis and his writings.

Clinging: The Experience of Prayer, by Emilie Griffin

A woman describes what the experience of prayer is like, as well as the changes it creates in a person's soul and life.

Why I picked it up: My sister had recommended this book to me, and I bought it within the last couple years from my favorite bookstore. I picked it up recently because I was trying to do that bookstore's summer reading challenge. Although I gave up on the challenge, I wanted to finish this book so I could reduce how many books I'm actively reading right now.

My impressions: Some of the first chapters were really thought provoking for me, and the author writes in a unique blend of metaphor and references to Scripture and poetry. I liked much of what the author had to say, and it made me desire to pray more often and pray well. Unfortunately, as I think back on the book, I have difficulty remembering specific details; I think this is a result of so many metaphors being employed, as opposed to practical, concrete details about how to pray with greater devotion. I think this can be a decent book for Catholics and Christian adults to consult as they seek to grow in prayer, but I suspect other works might have more practical applications.

The Invisible Child: On Reading and Writing Books for Children, by Katherine Paterson

Award-winning children's literature author Katherine Paterson shares her ideas on writing for children, and the role of children's literature, in a series of talks and speeches collected in this book.

Why I picked it up: A good friend of mine recommended that I borrow her copy of this book.

My impressions: I've never read this author's works, and although I think I'd be less than likely to enjoy them, I found she had some excellent insights into creativity, wonder, and writing for children. I wrote down many quotes. While I don't agree with all her ideas or much appreciate the heavy topics she tackles in her stories, I'm now curious enough to want to try reading two of her books. She makes me want to be a more creative type, a better writer, and someone who writes the story she can write. She doesn't sugarcoat her writing process: writing a good story is hard work, and even coming up with a plot is difficult. I appreciate that she owns she is an author of children's literature and that she defends that profession as not being something less-than compared with authorship for adults. For those who want some good food for thought on writing, and particularly on writing for children, this book would be a good choice.

Draft that I Beta-Read for Someone I Know

I'm not at liberty to discuss the contents of this work, but it is fiction.

Why I picked it up: The author asked me if I'd be interested in beta reading their draft. I've never beta read before, and I was excited to be asked!

My impressions: Again, I'm not at liberty to discuss, but I will say that I hope I get the chance to beta read the next book.

Until the Streetlights Come On: How a Return to Play Brightens Our Present and Prepares Kids for an Uncertain Future, by Ginny Yurich**

The founder of the 1000 Hours Outside movement writes about her experience of discovering the benefits nature provides to families and especially children who spend time outdoors.

Why I picked it up: I wanted an audiobook and this one, which I'd picked up on Audible a while back, sounded good to me.

My impressions: It's good to revisit the "nature is good!" genre, and this book is a great book both for those being introduced to the benefits of time outdoors, as well as casual readers like me who already believe nature has so much to offer modern Americans. Yurich includes many points that I cheer along with - what's the rush to educate kids formally? Isn't the college and sports track a rat race? There's a time and place for technology, but there's so much we're missing outside if that's all that we do. She does a great job of synthesizing many sources and presenting a compelling case for spending as much time outside as possible.  This book would be a great resource for families who want to learn about and possibly embrace a more outdoors-y lifestyle.

Bracket Play

The bracket is pretty small this month. As always, I paired weaker books against stronger ones in the first round. The audiobook about the benefits of letting children play outside won over the historical fiction work based on the ongoing violence between Constantinople and the Persian empire, Belisarius. Katherine Paterson's collection of essays on writing for children won over Baxter's analysis of Lewis' formation in Medieval texts - a good scholarly book, but not one that changed my understanding of Lewis too much. Paterson's book also won over the playing-in-nature book in the next round. I put Clinging, the book on prayer, in the best slot on account of its subject - and as excellent as I found parts of it to be, I chose The Invisible Child as the winner for this month. I felt like I was really engaged with Paterson's ideas, whether I agreed with them or not, while I currently have difficulty remembering many details about the book on prayer. 

Books Attempted and Put Down

Invisible Women: Data Bias in a World Designed for Men, by Caroline Criado Perez, read by the author**

A researcher provides data and stories to argue that the research we use to do so many things, from city planning to technology design, is skewed and fails women.

Why I picked it up: A gal pal said she'd listened to this audiobook and it sounded interesting.

Why I put it down: I found myself feeling dissatisfied with certain aspects of my life, even though I was calling out the author's bias as I listened. I figured that continuing to listen to this audiobook would lead me to focus on minor inconveniences that don't really matter to me, and I'm actually quite happy with the life I am privileged to live. I think there would have been a lot more to interest me in the book, but I didn't want to focus on so much negativity while I listened.

July 2026 Reading Bracket

Book Bracket July 2026

My year of reading is halfway over, but there are plenty more titles to be enjoyed! I was late getting this month's bracket posted because of my return to work.

The Poisoned King, by Katherine Rundell**

This sequel to Impossible Creatures follows Christopher back to the Archipelago to solve the mystery of the death of the great dragons, while the Princess Anya discovers an evil plot to take over her grandfather's kingdom.

Why I picked it up: One of my relatives really liked the first book. Even though I wasn't a huge fan of the original work, I figured I'd try this one out. It was available through my local library's e-system.

My impressions: I thought I'd give Katherine Rundell's writing another chance, and while some aspects of the book were better than I expected, I'm not glad that I committed to finishing it out. I remember being put-off by some of her analogies - in audiobook form, I think some of them worked better, but not always. The story of the princess was quite intriguing and I was caught up in it, but once she started focusing on her desire for revenge, she became a less compelling character. The book ended with most of the right notes regarding revenge, which was good, but I was made uncomfortable by a reference to an immortal being, this time reincarnated as a male (had been female in the previous book). There were references to creating an antidote that sounded a lot like making a magic potion (eye of this, heart of that, etc.), which is not my favorite sort of fantasy, and there's a legendarium or appendix at the end that talks about mythical creatures, the first one containing a story with an LGBTQ element. I can see how this sort of book might appeal to some readers, but Rundell's writing isn't for me, and outside of personal taste, I don't recommend this one, because there is no lack of excellent fantasy books to choose from.

Come to Mary's House: Spending Time with Our Blessed Mother,  by Shawn Chapman

A Discalced Secular Carmelite shares reflections on Our Lady, ending each of 39 reflections with an imaginative meditative exercise that invites readers to spend time encountering Mary in her house.

Why I picked it up: I acquired this book through a cousin book-exchange before Advent, and decided I needed to dip into it after it sat on my shelf for half a year. Yes, this is another book in the "anti-library" that I decided I needed to try.

My impressions: There are some very good reflections on Mary included in this work, some engaging personal stories, and moving imaginative meditations. However, I found that not every reflection or imaginative meditation reached me. As always, there were times when I was mentally ready to make time for reflecting, but much of the time, I was not. I think that this book could be a really powerful one for some readers, and I think the reflections might be more relatable to female readers. This book could be worth a try for someone who is interested in more imaginative prayer and/or is looking for a different way of encountering Mary.

Rebellion 1776, by Laurie Halse Anderson(*)

Elsbeth, a serving girl separated from her father, must wait out uncertainty in the midst of battle, changing employment, and plague.

Why I picked it up: I'd enjoyed another book by this author, and since it was buy-one-get-one-free at my school's book fair, I figured I'd give it a try.

My impressions: This book was an interesting picture inside Boston during the start and early part of the American Revolution, especially with smallpox raging in the city, but the story fell short in some ways. There were far too many descriptions of puking and poxy patients. The story was surprisingly sad at one point. While I found many characters multi-faceted, I didn't truly like any of them. The playing out of the smallpox issue within the story was interesting, but there was definitely a scene that felt like it was a historical version of COVID vaccine debates, with the scene playing out a little woodenly, too. I didn't like that the main character tried justifying her deception and stealing to herself, even though it made her feel awful - there was also a lack of negative repercussions for those actions. I didn't find this book as good a historical fiction as Tolliver's Secret or Carry On, Mr. Bowditch, so I wouldn't recommend reading this one.

A Lion to Guard Us, by Clyde Robert Bulla

In 1609, three children make their way across the ocean to reunite with their father in Jamestown.

Why I picked it up: I saw this on Audible and recommended reading lists and thought it would be interesting to try. This one was available through my alma mater's library.

My impressions: This book is a quick work of historical fiction about the early settling of America. I learned a bit about how people might come to make the move across the sea and felt some solid research underpinned this work. The story was simple and focused, which I liked, but I felt the illustrations were a little too stylized and, therefore, distracting. This is a quick read, and while I won't recommend it as a must-read, there's certainly nothing to object to, other than the deaths of some adults and a description of a poorly-made toy as a "demon doll." Mid and upper elementary readers could tackle this book without issue.

The Reb and the Redcoats, by Constance Savery, narrated by Karen Savage**

Four British children wonder why their once-warm injured uncle is so mean to the American prisoner of war during the time of the Revolutionary War.

Why I picked it up: I obtained this with an Audible credit at some point. I think I was intrigued by the story looking at an aspect of the Revolutionary War I hadn't considered before - that some soldiers would have been captured and held as prisoners of war.

My impressions: This book lacks a lot of action, but has enough interpersonal conflict to keep things interesting. This work of historical fiction depicted a time and place that felt real, and also portrayed characters doing realistic things. The story hangs well together, with an object introduced in the first paragraphs showing up and playing an important role through the length of the story. There's some discussion of a doll working "magic", but I didn't get the sense that this was a significant element in the story, and pretty easy to gloss over. Readers will still enjoy happy and complete lives without reading this book, but it could be a good one for upper elementary readers who are interested in a slightly more British look at the Revolutionary War.

The Light Princess, by George MacDonald, narrated by Fox in the Stars**

This fairy tale about a weightless princess depicts the beauty of giving one's life in love for another.

Why I picked it up: I'm starting to get concerned about being able to finish a reading challenge this summer, and this book gave me twice as many points as the other books I've been reading. I accessed this one through Librivox (thus, the interesting name of the narrator).

My impressions: This fairy tale can get pretty sad in one or two parts, but it is a beautiful story and worth revisiting from time to time. I'm not sure that this one was written to be read aloud, but it is still very good. I like that the author doesn't just establish an oddity - that a princess has no gravity; he explains or hints at some different ways this problem is truly a problem, and not just a plot device. The prince is truly noble, and I think the best part is seeing how his love transforms his beloved. This might be a good read-aloud (or would it be?), but elementary readers would probably be able to tackle this story.

Tree and Leaf, by J. R. R. Tolkien

This slim volume is a combination of his famous essay, "On Fairy-Stories," and his short story "Leaf by Niggle."

Why I picked it up: I needed to reference the essay for something I'm writing, and wanted to finish the volume for the purpose of some reading challenges I'm doing this summer. Grateful once again for university libraries, which sometimes have books available when I need them!

My impressions: Still so good, even on the third or fourth reading. If you are interested in the creative life, this book is a very interesting look into it; it's theory, but also art. The essay is excellent, even if the beginning is a bit slow, but I love Tolkien's writing. The short story is simple and beautiful. People should read this.

St. John Henry Newman A Doctor of the Church for Our Time: Spiritual Guide for the Catholic Heart, by Sr. Mary Catherine Blanding, IHM

A religious sister introduces Americans to the newest Doctor of the Church, St. John Henry.

Why I picked it up: I have a personal connection with the author, attended a university named for this saint, and wanted to learn more about him.

My impressions: This is a great introductory work, but it's also important to treat it more like meditation material than a biography. I felt called out by some of the things this saint had to say, but was also encouraged and shown areas where I could work on my relationship with God. There is some biographical information, but I liked that the author spent more time discussing major themes St. John Henry concerned himself with, as well as his personal convictions. She really brought home just how relevant this Victorian saint is to our time. This is a great book for anyone who is not familiar with the saint and would like a place to start.

Runaway Ralph, by Beverly Cleary

The motorcycle-loving Ralph from The Mouse and the Motorcycle feels suffocated by his family's priorities and runs away to what he imagines will be a grand time at a summer camp.

Why I picked it up: This is a book my husband and I read together this summer.

My impressions: The first chapter was dynamite. The rest of the book couldn't live up to that high standard, but it was still excellent in so many ways. We laughed throughout the reading of the book and were happy to share how much we enjoyed that incredible first chapter. The plot did feel a little weak, but the ending was satisfactory. This would be a good book for younger elementary readers after they've read the first book in the series.

The Magician's Nephew, by C. S. Lewis, narrated by Kenneth Branagh**

This book from the "Chronicles of Narnia" series introduces readers to the origins of Narnia when two children in Victorian England travel to different worlds by means of a vain uncle's magic rings.

Why I picked it up: I'm continuing to read through this series with cousins, and this was the next book on the list. I started reading the physical book but eventually transferred to the audio version.

My impressions: This book is so good! I actually got a little creeped out by the dying world, which is often one of my favorite parts, but it wasn't so bad once I moved to the audiobook version. C. S. Lewis can feel a little heavy-handed at times when it comes to communicating a message in this series, but it still works. It's still an engaging adventure. This book, as well as all the other Narnia books, should be read by pretty much everyone who is upper elementary age or older. Well, I don't have such positive feelings for the final book, but that is future Jessica's problem.

A Right To Be Merry, by Mother Mary Francis, P.C.

A Poor Clare nun beautifully writes about life as a contemplative in a newly-established monastery.

Why I picked it up: This book was recommended to me by a family member who is discerning a vocation to become a religious sister. I've been yearning to find this book, and finally realized that my alma mater had a copy! Happy day! Although, this copy is old enough that the author was known as "Sister Mary Francis" rather than "Mother Mary Francis".

My impressions: Wow, this book was even better than I thought it would be! It's been a while since I've marveled at the quality of writing in a book - I think Elizabeth Goudge was the last author to amaze me this way. I wrote down a lot of quotes from this book and wouldn't mind acquiring this one for my own library. I do wonder if Poor Clare orders still live in the manner described in the book (pre-Vatican II), but even if changes have occurred, I think this book captures the spirituality of St. Francis and St. Clare - and shows the beauty of contemplative life so charmingly - I still think it is relevant for Catholics today. The author does briefly discuss the penances and difficulties that are part of the life of a contemplative nun, but she focuses much more of her time on the joys of her life. This is a great book for Catholics of all ages to enjoy, I think, starting with as young as mature middle schoolers.

The Extraordinary Education of Nicholas Benedict, by Trenton Lee Stewart, narrated by Del Roy**

This prequel of sorts to the "Mysterious Benedict Society" series introduces readers to the orphan Nicholas Benedict as he faces challenges in a new orphanage, including bullying, loneliness, and narcolepsy.

Why I picked it up: I saw a family member reading one of the other books that take place later in the series. I looked up a different book by this author, found it was unavailable as an audiobook at the time, but discovered this one available through my library's e-system.

My impressions: The book was pretty lengthy, but it had a lot of good elements in it. A timeless quality in a fun setting - who wouldn't enjoy exploring a manor-converted-to-orphanage with Nicholas and his friends? Those friends were developed well, and the main character displayed some excellent growth. There were some elements of mystery, but it was not a mystery book. As I recall from reading other books in the series, there continued to be an implication that, if you're extraordinary and clever enough, maybe the rules don't apply to you. The ending wrapped up all the loose strings as well. This book would be worth considering to read if you've enjoyed the books in the "Mysterious Benedict Society", which is good for middle grade audiences.

The Elements of Style, 4th Edition, by William Strunk Jr. and E. B. White

A resource for writing well, including sections on grammar, misused words, and style.

Why I picked it up: I purchased this book years ago. I started reading it months ago and bogged down. This summer, I decided it was time to finish reading it. I want to improve my writing skills.

My impressions: This book sometimes was so slow that I got bogged down. However, I wish that it was something that had been suggested to me during my high school or college education. It is just a beginning place; a reference book; a collection of some writers' opinions; but it is a great starting place if you're trying to write well. I haven't applied much (if anything) so far, but I hope to revisit it in some future revision activities.

Bracket Play

Thirteen books this month made for another full bracket. I paired as many similar books as I could in the first round, which took slight precedence over pairing weakest books against strongest ones. That's why some good books didn't make it past the first or second round, when they very well deserved to do so. Included in the books that I felt should have gone further in the competition were the writing guide The Elements of Style and The Light Princess. I'd also give the same distinction to The Extraordinary Education of Nicholas Benedict, which maybe should have won that first round...but I couldn't deny that the first chapter of Runaway Ralph is the strongest one that I've read of any book, children or adult, for a long time.

The second round sent one really good book out of the fight, Tolkien's Tree and Leaf, a great little work with some of his most iconic thoughts on Story, as well as one of the best short stories I've ever read. Runaway Ralph fell to Lewis' The Magician's Nephew, which was fantastic as an audiobook narrated by Kenneth Branagh. I was glad that the book about St. John Henry, by a local author, made it through this round, as did the Poor Clare book, A Right to Be Merry. 

In the closing battles, Lewis' fantasy beat the book about St. John Henry, but ultimately fell to A Right to Be Merry, a book so beautifully written and so encompassing of the spirit of St. Francis and St. Clare of Assisi that I would happily read it again - and, indeed, aspire to own it someday. This is a deserving winner for the month.

Books Attempted and Put Down

Christy, by Catherine Marshall

Idealistic young Christy volunteers to teach at a poor mission church in the Appalachians, and finds her soul expanding and maturing in response to the extreme poverty, violence, and beauty she encounters there.

Why I picked it up: This was a book chosen for one of my book clubs.

My impressions: I made it through quite a bit of the book, skimming some sections here and there, before I finally decided to quit. There were parts of the story that I liked quite a bit - it had Christian messages without being too preachy, it took a good look at hard things, it had some elements that were a little reminiscent of the Little House books, like their regional foods and preparations. However, there were some pretty bald conversations about adult topics, including rape and infant death. I won't say there was no plot to the book, but the plot that it had was certainly unconventional. Maybe that's because the book was focused very much on the change in Christy as well as the events happening around her. I think I put it down because I reached a point where I thought, "They're really talking about that?" one too many times (another adult topic), and I wasn't interested enough in seeing how she changes from being engaged to one man to...well, I won't spoil it here.

Lincoln's Lady Spymaster: The Untold Story of the Abolitionist Southern Belle Who Helped Win the Civil War, by Gerri Willis** (narrated by??)

Biography of Elizabeth ..., who from the heart of the Confederacy ran a spy ring in service of the Union.

Why I picked it up: I came across this on my library's app and it sounded interesting.

Why I put it down: My experience with the first book of the month helped me decide to put the book down - even though I was 80% finished. There was far less information about the subject and her life than I expected, and too much about the Civil War and its events in general. Too much time spent on other people - John Wilkes Booth, Ulysses Grant, etc. I'd gotten probably what I was going to get from listening to the book, and I moved on to others.

The Scarlet Pimpernel, by Baroness Orczy*

An Englishman navigates a potentially treacherous relationship with his wife as he disguises himself to save French noblemen in danger of death by the French Revolution's guillotine.

Why I picked it up: I've read this one before, but some friends wanted to read it for book club, so I obtained it in ebook form.

Why I put it down: Honestly, there was too much focus on the relationship of the married couple. While I'm getting back into attempting books that have clean romantic elements, I'm still pretty limited. It's good to have tried this one, and I'd possibly be interested in trying other books in this series if there's more focus on the adventure side of things.

The Sword in the Stone, by T. H. White, narrated by Jason Neville**

Wart learns much from his magical tutor, Merlin, in old England.

Why I picked it up: I read this in elementary school and wanted to try it out again. Available through my state's e-library.

Why I put it down: There were some elements of the writing that I didn't like, and I just felt too familiar with the Disney version to really enjoy this retelling. I figured my time would be better spent on something I enjoyed listening to more.

June 2026 Book Bracket

Book Bracket for June

This month saw the completion of many books, some from my "anti-library," but others more spontaneous.

Blue Willow, by Doris Gates

Janey, always moving with her parents after they lost the ranch in the dust bowl, are in a place she finds she wants to stay permanently, but even in uncertainty, she finds consolation and perhaps a means of staying there in a Blue Willow china plate.

 Why I picked it up: I acquired this book a long time ago, I think for free - the "Newbery Honor" designation probably appealed to me. It's been part of my "anti-library" for years, and this summer, I'm working on knocking out some titles from the anti-library.

My impressions: I didn't think this book would have much to appeal to me, but it had me invested by the end after a moving scene or two. Not a lot happens as far as action goes, but the author does a great job of creating a plot that is realistic and gets the reader to care about what happens. There were a few comments about Janey noticing her friend's darker skin - I don't think those were necessarily problematic, but I do want to mention the formal "N" word is used to describe a black man. I thought the ending was very satisfying. I probably won't hold on to this book, I think it's a pretty good one for an  introduction to the Depression and migrant workers.

Echo Mountain, by Lauren Wolk, narrated by Holly Linneman**

Ellie's family had to make a life on the mountain following the stock market crash, but when she takes on the burden of the secret of what really happened on the day her father was injured and fell into a coma, she finds friends more willing to accept her than some of her own family.

Why I picked it up: I aquired this book for free from someone somewhere, but to get it out of my "anti-library", I found it through my local library's audiobook selection.

My impressions: The author presents a very reflective book that captures the desperation of economic hard times and the absence of a protective, providing father. The main character is intriguing, as is the "wild" life she leads as she harvests food from the mountain. There are some good messages in here about not judging based on appearances or incomplete information, as well as the importance of caring for the world and not just taking from it. However, regardless of the merits of this story as a work of historical fiction, I ended up disagreeing with the way some events played out - spoilers ahead. Ellie, the main character, decides to spare her siblings from the truth that they both, in different ways, contributed to a tree falling on their father, sending him into a coma. The consequences are unfair, with both her mother and her sister keeping her at arm's length from their affection. She maintains this silence to the end, and feels vindicated that her father knows the truth, even if nobody else does. I took issue with this part because I felt like the better course to take would have been to be honest about the incident. Even if she wasn't believed fully, it would have been better to have an additional narrative for the family to consider, instead of ostracizing one of their own. The second issue I had was that Ellie seemed unrealistically understanding and adult-like in her reflections and conversation - I believe 12-year-olds can have deep thoughts, but I the thoughts she has are not what I'd expect from a girl her age. Finally, I was frustrated by the continuing trope that a child ends up knowing better than an adult. While this may be true in some circumstances, Ellie's blatant refusal to obey her mother in some regards really rubbed me the wrong way. Towards the end, a few characters ask, "Tell me what is true?", throwing into question the idea of objective truth. I considered stopping reading this book, but I think I finished it because I was frustrated with the characters and wanted to see how things ended up. I also want to note there are some scenes where pretty gnarly wounds are described and that's not something that every reader would be cool with. I wouldn't recommend this book. It isn't bad, but it has some elements that I didn't like. If you want an introduction to the difficulties of the Great Depression, I think Blue Willow would be a better place to start.

Women of the Catholic Imagination: Twelve Inspired Novelists You Should Know, edited by Haley Stewart

Scholars present essays on the works and lives of twelve famous female Catholic novelists from the last century and a half.

Why I picked it up: I was intrigued by the title when I saw it on the Word on Fire website, and asked for it as a gift. I wanted to move this one off my "anti-library" list as well, and was glad to add some variety to my recent reading fare.

My impressions: As wonderful and impressive as the works and lives of these Catholic women were/are, this book has me thinking that I don't think I want to become a great novelist. Expect more on this in a different blog post. It was interesting to see how different these authors were and how their faith came out in their (sometimes very secular) works. I was familiar with only about half of the authors presented, and I hadn't even read the books of several of the ones I'd heard of before, so this was a very informative book. I like that the essays provided biographical information as well as some literary analysis, and each section concluded with a list of suggested reading and a blurb about the academic who penned the essay. This book is basically an advertisement to go hunt down some little-known novels, and I think it's great that someone wanted to discuss the literature that Catholic women have been writing the last 150 years or so. I did end up skimming a few parts (often analyses of difficult parts of the authors' works), and I would say that this book would be best for Catholic adults looking for some new-to-them authors who wrote hefty novels.

With God In Russia: The Inspiring Classic Account of a Catholic Priest's Twenty-Three Years in Soviet Prisons and Labor Camps, by Walter J. Ciszek, S.J., with Daniel L. Flaherty, S.J.

This memoir shares about the life of Father Walter Ciszek, who spent two-plus decades ministering to God's people in Communist Russia, first in disguise as a laborer, then through his trials in the prisons and labor camps of the U.S.S.R., his life as a "free" man, and his return home.

Why I picked it up: I loved Fr. Ciszek's next book, He Leadeth Me, and I wanted some more of the details about what actually happened to him in Russia - and it turns out, there was a whole book that shares that story! I found this copy at my favorite local bookstore.

My impressions: This book was heavy (understandably), but I felt like I learned so much about the U.S.S.R. by reading about Fr. Ciszek's experiences there. I will also not be picking up anything about Soviet Russia for a while. Fr. Ciszek did mention God's providence and protection from time to time, but I think his other book, He Leadeth Me, carries the spiritual message, whereas this book focused on the biographical information of his life. His youth fascinated me, including his choices to do the hard thing simply because it was hard. What an intriguing person! I could also see how his toughness earlier in life stood him in good stead during his privations in Russia. This was a pretty lengthy account, but it was good. It is a book to make one grateful for small blessings, and probably best for readers high school or older who are not sensitive readers and would like to learn about life in Communist Russia.

The Last Dragon on Mars, by Scott Reintgen, narrated by Landon Woodson**

Lunar's attempt to recover treasure from the wastes of Mars results in an adventure beyond his imagination, involving dragons and space travel.

Why I picked it up: A family member said he really enjoyed this book, so I figured I'd give it a try, too. It was available through my state's e-library.

My impressions: This was an impressive middle-grade adventure novel, right up there with Glitch from earlier this year. I don't want to say more than I already have in the sentence summary above to avoid spoilers, but it was a wild ride. You do have to go into it knowing that there's not a Christian worldview underpinning the world-building - humanity is not brought about by an act of creation by God, but through other means - but otherwise, one could say there are some themes that align with Christianity. There even seems to be a subtle distinction between just anger and sinful anger, with just anger being a force to change injustices, and sinful anger being a rage in which people can lose themselves. I do admit I felt a little uncomfortable with dragons "choosing" humans, as well as the special bond between them (instead of being chosen by God for a mission, being chosen by dragon? I may be reading into it). However, I don't think it's something that would be worth putting down the book for. If you want a fantasy adventure in a sci-fi setting, look no further than this book! This book would probably be best for middle grade readers and older.

Sammy Keyes and the Hotel Thief, by Wendelin Van Draanen

Sammy is about to start seventh grade when she witnesses a crime committed through her binoculars...and then waves at the criminal, starting a quest to find the thief before he finds her.

Why I picked it up: This one lived on my to-read list for a while, and then I found a physical copy at a library sale. It was an anti-library selection that I knew I needed to tackle.

My impressions: With the exception of a few scenes, this was a very enjoyable and exciting mystery. The stakes and concerns were realistic, and the main character has one of the strongest narrator voices I've heard in a while - her narration sounds like she's telling the story out loud to you. I like Sammy's gumption and how much she really seemed like a middle school student. I didn't like a scene where she talks to a robbery victim in her workplace - the victim is an astrologist, and goes into detail about a birth chart - not something I'd want my kids to be reading about, and not necessary for the story, either. Fortunately, this was a short section. There was one snotty classmate I really disliked, and I think Sammy's way of dealing with her bullying was a bit extreme - and it would definitely violate some HIPAA laws today. Sammy disobeys or doesn't tell her grandmother everything, which isn't great, but I think it's pretty clear that Sammy wasn't right to do those things, and knows it. With the exception of a page or two about some astrological stuff, it was a fun book that I was excited to finish, and would be good for upper elementary and middle school readers.

Listening for Lions, by Gloria Whelan

Rachel's parents die of influenza and she agrees to masquerade as a greedy couple's dead daughter, the couple hoping she will restore them to the good graces of the husband's distant and wealthy father.

Why I picked it up: Same situation as the previous book.

My impressions: I wasn't sure if I'd like this book since I wasn't a huge fan of one or two of the author's other works. Her tendency to tell stories about children in situations where they're taken advantage of until they overcome, while evident here, felt milder than in her other works, so it was more enjoyable. The beginning and end of the book were a little slower paced than the middle part, but it was still enjoyable, and I found it quick to read. The main character is likeable and one roots for her to succeed. There is a good exploration of the importance of telling the truth and the experience of unexpectedly good outcomes from difficult circumstances, although one or two comments indicated telling the truth was complicated, and didn't go much further than that. Also one comment about different takes two missionaries had on polygamy and church involvement. I found the author's consistent use of African animals in similes a little off - it wasn't bad, it just happened throughout the book and didn't quite work for me There's just the faintest hint of feminist ideas, but they don't distract from the story and almost everything plays out believably. This book would be fine for upper elementary and middle school readers to look into. While I don't think that it's a must-read, I do think it's good.

The Phantom Tollbooth, by Norton Juster, narrated by Rainn Wilson**

Upon discovering a car and tollbooth in his bedroom one day, the blasé Milo embarks on a stimulating journey with a ticking dog and a blustering bug through lands of words, numbers, and sounds to save the Princesses Rhyme and Reason from their prison in the land of the demons.

Why I picked it up: I remembered reading the book as a child and acquired it cheaply at some point. It was mentioned on a podcast as someone's favorite or most influential book growing up, and it made me want to revisit this book I recalled enjoying but barely recall now.

My impressions: I'm not going to lie - the beginning was so slow and dull that I had a hard time continuing to listen to the audiobook. However, once Milo got to more of the adventure of the story, and less of just meeting embodied puns or turns of phrase, I found the book much more enjoyable. The deeper meaning of the book definitely went over my head when I was younger, but I appreciate its championing of the adventure it can be to learn. I think this book would be fun to read out loud, but many elementary aged independent readers might be able to read this book - although some words might be difficult to work out ("dodecahedron", for example).

33 Years in the Holy Land: What Jesus Saw from Bethlehem to Golgotha, by Fr. A. G. Sertillanges

The priest who wrote What Jesus Saw From the Cross also wrote a shorter set of meditations on Jesus' life leading up to Holy Week.

Why I picked it up: I ordered this book to give to my Dad for Father's Day since he'd wanted to read What Jesus Saw From the Cross. I decided I needed to read it before I gave it to him.

My impressions: This book was another great set of meditations to sit with. Not meant to be read cover to cover in a single sitting, this book begins with the Nativity, goes through his infancy and hidden life, and considers different aspects of His ministry, including His relationship with His disciples, the authorities of the time, and nature. It's a short read, but full of beautiful reflections. It's a great book for any Christian or Catholic, possibly as young as middle school.

The Last of the Really Great Whangdoodles, by Julie Andrews Edwards

Three children befriend an award-winning geneticist and overcome resistance to explore a fantastical land and meet the remarkable creature who rules there, the last of the whangdoodle species.

Why I picked it up: This book made it onto my to-read list sometime, and I obtained it through inter-library loan.

My impressions: This book was definitely a mixed bag of impressions: the opening third was pretty slow moving (sometimes painfully slow), the middle section was a pretty cool adventure with fantastical creatures, and the last bit just got weird. It was a fun, whimsical adventure that took a decidedly weird scientific turn at the end - cloning was apparently the answer? I really didn't like the final speech one character made about playing God with genetics and at least trying to do it in a honorable, decent way. Because of that element, I wouldn't recommend this book - I definitely take issue with the idea of going ahead with scientific work even if, it is implied, it's outside what God intended. However, outside the weird genetic stuff and the beginning that felt really slow at times, there were some definite positives in the book, such as the enchanting highlights of Whangdoodleland, the importance of imagination, using good manners, and watching for temptations that feed on our virtues as well as those that appeal to our vices. I don't recommend reading this book.

The Rise of Neptune, by Scott Reintgen, narrated by Landon Woodson, Kevin R. Free, and Gail Shalan**

The second book of the Dragonships series, Lunar Jones, the dragon Dread, and the dragon crew must fight to survive against an enemy whose abilities they did not anticipate.

Why I picked it up: I LOVED the first book in this series, recommended by a relative. I was eager to try out the second in the series; the third comes out later this year.

My impressions: Wow, a great sequel to a great first book, with only one or two lines that I have to complain about. Action, stakes, world building, interesting characters, all these elements were fantastic. The issues I had were these: there were more references to dragons going to the bathroom than I would like. Second issue: there was a moment when a male character wondered if a [male] dragon had a crush on him, before realizing it was a girl who was crushing. That was just weird - no thanks, but at least it was just one sentence. Even so, it's a sentence I'd like parents to know about before letting their child read this book. There is also an element of romance - crushes, specifically - that is introduced in this book after being absent in the first one. It's not my favorite, but I think it's pretty mild and not problematic. The book is great at being a complete adventure, but it definitely would not make as much sense without the first book; it sets up well for the next book, too. With a caution regarding the elements I mentioned earlier, and a reminder that this book is is a fantasy and doesn't have the Christian understanding of human origins, this book is a lot of fun and a great adventure.

Lilibet Lynn and the Children of Sherwood: A Thimble in Time Adventure, by Elizabeth Amy Hajek*

Lilibet turns twelve, and after her Mom starts acting weird, encounters a magical thimble that allows her to time travel to Nottingham in the time of the Robin Hood legends.

Why I picked it up: I had to read a self-published book for my own reading challenge, and I'd purchased this one several years back.

My impressions: The reimagining of the Robin Hood legend was from a unique angle - looking at key characters as children - but I can't say that it was a story that I found captivating. Part of that might have come from the necessary set-up: a young girl suddenly finds herself traveling through time, and she doesn't understand the mechanics of it, so that takes time to explore. The story felt very historically accurate for the most part, which was good, but the historicity felt too in-your-face at times. The ending of her time travel was the one part that didn't feel historically accurate to me, but it brought everything together. The books sets up well for a sequel. I think this book might hit the spot for the right audience - maybe upper elementary female readers - but I don't consider it a must-read.

Bracket Play

Another month of solid book numbers, and another month of easy first round picks. I purposely paired weaker books with stronger ones in the first round. As it turns out, just a few books in my "anti-library" made it past round one - significant, considering that half the titles this month are from my collection of unread books.

In round two, the choices were still pretty straightforward - both Dragonship series books moved on, as well as Fr. Sertillanges' book of meditations on the life of Christ before his Passion. While this latter book made it to the final round, I feel guilty for once again picking a secular book as the best one I read this month. As beautiful as some of the reflections were in Fr. Sertillanges' book, I was really swept away by The Last Dragon on Mars. It's a month where I wish I could have two winners, but I have to narrow it down to just one.

Books Attempted and Put Down

Daughter of the Mountains, by Louise Rankin

Momo has longed for a special dog, like the Buddhist monks have, but when she finally obtains one, it is stolen and she must embark on a journey to recover it.

Why I picked it up: Again, the Newbery Honor sticker appealed to me, and I found it cheap at a local Bookaholic store. I attempted it since it's in my "anti-library".

Why I put it down: There was a lot of focus on Buddhism, more than I was comfortable with for a story about a girl trying to recover her dog. If it had been passing, I wouldn't have minded, I think, but there was a lot of talk about demons, too, and I just didn't need that in my life. I skimmed the book, and I don't know if I would have enjoyed this or not otherwise. In any case, I'm alright with moving another book to the "discard" pile and freeing up more time for books that I'll probably enjoy reading more.

Fablehaven: Rise of the Evening Star, by Brandon Mull*

Seth and Kendra rejoin their grandparents at Fablehaven, the reserve that protects mythical creatures, both light and dark, in the hopes that the enchanted grounds can save them from the evil Society of the Evening Star and traitors in their midst.

Why I picked it up: One of my book clubs was reading this.

Why I put it down: I was alternately uncomfortable with the dark creatures (some referred to as "demons") and feeling to sucked into the story. I really enjoyed some of it, but ultimatly, decided it was best for me to put the book down. I skimmed most of the second half of the book, and still understood much of what was going on with the help of Wikipedia. It's not my favorite fantasy series, so I'm okay with putting this one down and focusing on other books.