Traditional Text, Audio, or E-book?
The 39 Steps by John Buchan is the strongest bookish association I have with beginning this blog. I started this book, a secret agent-style adventure set during the eve of world-wide war, around December of 2019, the eve of a new year. My memories of this book are of listening to it in my bedroom at home, and of walking around a chilly park as Richard Hannay runs around Scotland. Shortly after, in February of 2020, I would begin pitting books against each other in brackets, sharing my favorite reads of each month.
Even though I missed reporting on this particular book by a few months, its connection to the inception of Book Brackets remains with me. Perhaps the reason is that I listened to this book as an audiobook, and I had to decide if audiobooks would count towards my "books read" summary. I had just recently dipped my toe into the world of audiobooks when I listened to this one. Even if I finished listening to the book, or other audiobooks, could I still claim that I had read them?
In the end, I decided that I could count them, but their inclusion has led me to refine how I choose which books to enjoy in audio, electronic, and traditional print form in the years since the blog began.
Pros and Cons
The three book formats that I enjoy (audiobook, e-book, and traditional print) all have features that make them ideal for some circumstances, but poor choices for others. While I acknowledge that everyone will have their own opinions about what makes a certain book format work or fail, there could be some benefit gained from considering one person's lived experience of varying book forms.
Audiobooks
Pros:
Audiobooks really shine in situations where one cannot sit down to read: driving in the car; going for a walk; working out at the gym; doing chores at home. For those who can enjoy them, there is no need to fear a short "books read" list at the end of the year. Indeed, for those who want to finish more books, rather than fewer, the speed at which an audiobook plays can be increased. Alternatively, the speed can decrease for those who want to really take their time and soak in the words. Audiobooks can spare a voice a good deal of strain when something is to be read aloud, making them ideal for roadtrips. Excellent narrators, and even full-cast productions, can enliven the experience of enjoying the book. While some audiobook platforms charge seemingly exorbitant amounts, many can be enjoyed for free via library systems and Librivox, the platform that provides volunteer-narrated public domain works gratis.
Cons:
The quality of narration makes a big difference in an audiobook, particularly with Librivox recordings. Some people may find that the technological savvy required for audiobooks is a barrier to their enjoyment. Indeed, even with professionally produced audiobooks, there is the possibility of coming across a work that has misplaced chapters (this happened to me once). More obscure works may be difficult to find in this format, and some audiobooks are accessible only for high prices. I have also found that audiobooks are not an ideal format for tackling intellectually challenging works. It can be easy to tune out a work that is demanding or just a little dull.
One final negative remains for audiobooks: some people just cannot enjoy books this way. And, frankly, there's not a workaround for this. If listening to a book is not enjoyable to a person, then an audiobook is not the format for him or her.
E-books
Pros:
E-books are great for accessing works in the public domain. Project Gutenberg is the go-to website for such works. E-readers are devices that are small, light, and portable. Their charge holds for a long time and they can store a large number of titles. Some e-readers connect with phone apps, so that a reader can access a book whether they remembered to bring their e-reader with them or forgot it at home. Digital features allow for the font size to be increased, making them more accessible to some readers. E-books tend to be at least a bit cheaper than printed books. It is easier to interact with the text in an e-book, since there are functions for highlight passages and taking notes. These devices also have the unique benefit of approximating one's reading speed, so that a reader can determine how much more of the book is left to be read based on projected amount of time, page, or amount of book completed so far.
Cons:
While portable and sometimes sporting cheaper options than a traditional print book, an e-book lacks the physicality that makes something printed so appealing. While one can interact with the text through various functions, they are not always quite as convenient as what a physical book allows for. No physical bookmarks to indicate an interesting passage: rather, the need to navigate a digital menu to access flagged areas. For this reason, a highly demanding text may not have its ideal format as the e-book. Another area of concern is how the e-reader means of tracking progress may not build up the healthiest habits, because viewing a book as "25% completed" makes it sound like the goal of reading is to check books off a list - the faster, the better. And, on a less serious note, saying "I'm 42% of the way through the book" sounds way too specific and, frankly, a strange way of communicating progress. It sounds more natural to say "I'm almost halfway done." Finally, e-books that are checked out through library e-systems tend to have about half as long in a library member's possession, and if there are others waiting to read it, there's not really a good way to just keeping it longer and deal with the consequences of late returns.
Traditional Print Books
Pros:
Nothing beats a physical book. There may be situations when it makes sense to use an audiobook or e-book for cost or convenience, but the physical reality of a printed book speaks volumes (if you'll allow a pun) to a reader. A bookmark in a long book provides a very real sense of accomplishment as it slowly moves deeper into the book. The heft of a book, the pages, and even the smell of a vintage novel are extremely grounding elements that only a traditional print book enjoys. In fact, I think that there is something so important about the physicality of a book that I would argue that the best experiences of reading - especially for getting emotionally invested - are achieved only through reading physical books. Just looking at the last year, only two months had winners that were not in print form. I would estimate that at least half the books I read each year are audiobooks, so the fact that my favorites skew so heavily to physical books is, I think, telling. Even if I can get emotionally invested in an audiobook, I think that the best books tend to be more demanding or appeal to me as physical reads - if I really want to enjoy a book, I want to sit and read it, not listen to it.
Print is the best option for intellectually demanding works, since its margins provide space for notes and sticky notes or other markers can indicate important passages. Difficult-to-find obscure titles are probably going to be available somewhere, but likely only in print form. Some really beautiful books are made that are worthy of showcasing as decorations. Print books are also the only real option for loaning a favorite title to someone else. One can't simply press an audiobook or e-book into a friends hands and say, "Here, read this and tell me what you think when you finish!"
Cons: Printed books take up a lot of space. They are heavy. And they tend to be expensive. They can get damaged or go missing or be inaccessible to readers for a variety of reasons. But I think the pros far outweigh the cons for print books.
Considerations for Book Format
I don't have enough of a system to provide an idea of a flowchart for choosing the best format for enjoying a book, but below are some ideas for what to think about.
1) Do you have an e-reader that you are willing to use? In the event that you do, then e-books are a nice option to consider for both availability and price. If an e-readers is not accessible to you, then you don't need to consider if e-books are a good option.
2) Is the book in the public domain? If so, then you will likely be able to find it in all three formats. Your preference can have more play in this situation, so long as you have access to the means of enjoying audiobooks or e-books.
3) If the book isn't in the public domain, can you access it through your local library? This avenue might be best for books you don't want to buy or just want to give a try without the commitment of paying for it. Library shelves are great places for impulse tries and catalogs of electronic items are fun to click through as well.
4) Do you anticipate really enjoying this work? If so, I would recommend finding a physical copy. If it's just something to keep you occupied while completing chores, but you don't think your life will be changed by it, audiobooks might be a better option.